i really feel the need to address this. cosleeping is safe when done with certain safeguards. the AAP acknowledgeds the benefits cosleeping have to breastfeeding and bonding but also feel it may increase the risk of SIDS. yet, no detailed information is given in regards to studies and percentages. in the past, they had clumped babies who slept in an adult bed all together.
from jan 1990 to dec 1997, 515 deaths of children under 2(fyi sids usually is only considering under one so this number is actually higher than would be considered for sids) sleeping in an adult bed. out of these, only 121 deaths were attributed to someone rolling on the baby. that is 121 deaths in 8 years time. the problem with this information is it makes no differentiation between what type of bed(such as a waterbed, sofa, or heavy pillowtop), of who else was in the bed(including other children esp toddlers, noninterested adult), or the state of the parent(drug or alchohol use, overtired, ). these are high risk details which would contribute to the danger.
now a sober, nonsmoking adult in bed is thought to be consciously aware, and not roll over their baby. aside from rolling, the suffocation risk can be eliminated with following cautions in regards to thick bedding, sharing blankets, overheating, proximity to areas that a baby could get wedged, overweight parent, smoking parent, and laying the baby anything but on the back.
also regarding these numbers, keep in mind, the back to sleep campaign didnt start until 1992, so any numbers in the beginning are actually higher than the last 5 years since each year deaths lowered after the campaign.
also, most other countries cosleep and have lower sids deaths than the us. that is even more reason to consider the simple fact of bedding and mattress choices being a major cause, not sharing the bed. in-bed cosleepers eliminate any concern for any of these issues.
the original cause of media release came came from statistics of about 60 babies each year for 3 years that die in an adult bed(again, this is an adult bed, not cosleeping). the problem is they fail to mention that every year 2500 children die of sids, so obviously the overwhelming majority says sids deaths occur primarily in cribs.
and finally, we must not be too naive. the fact is if you tell a medical examiner you cosleep, he will then do an autopsy, and when he finds no cause of death(which is the case with sids), then he will assume overlay by the parent unjustly. those poor mothers being told it was their fault. we have to think logically. if a certain number of babies die each year of sids, and a certain number of babies cosleep, then of course, some babies would die of sids while cosleeping.
googling "cosleeping sids" , you will find tons of articles. i know your thread wasnt specifically regarding this, but i dont want someone else considering cosleeping to be made fearful. there are many parents who choose to cosleep as a parenting idea. they really enjoy it and all the benefits it gives both the parents and the child. there are other parents that do so to get their baby too sleep, and it works so you would theorize it is what nature intended. those parents then become very happy with thier situation. im not by any means saying everyone should cosleep, but i am saying there are absolutely no documented negative effects, only positive benefits. it is not giving in or a bad habit, it is a parenting decision, no different than when to start solids.
thank you and sorry to hijack your post.